Watch This Debate
Report This Debate
Forward This Debate
Debate Comments
Bookmark This Page
Category: Arts

search and seizure of lockers and backpacks

This debate began on Thursday, May 01, 2008, 1:09:36 PM Pacific Time.
Who Won This Debate?
 
Vote For futuresuccess
13 Votes
 
Vote For theLwerd
10 Votes
 
 
Pro"In Favor"
The Instigator: futuresuccess
futuresuccess
Versus
Con"Against"
The Contender: theLwerd
theLwerd
 
 
Pro ~ Round 1

I am in favor of there being search and siezures in students back packs and lockers. Too many students these day are bringing uncalled for things to school such as, guns, drugs, energy drinks, and fireworks.
 
Con ~ Round 1

Lockers and backpacks exist in various locations - not just schools. For instance many gyms and fitness centers provide lockers to their members, and a lot of individuals utilize backpacks in their every day lives for convenience. Their usage is not limited to students in grades K-12 -- are you suggesting that law enforcement have the right to stop someone on the street and inspect their belongings? If so, why limit it to just backpacks? Why not search through every woman's purse or every businessman's briefcase? The fact of the matter is that people make bad decisions all the time. Infringing upon people's right to privacy will not eliminate the problem. In most cases, determined individuals will find a way to get around the rules anyway (i.e. putings drugs/guns in their pocket, or smuggling those dangerous and fatal Red Bulls or other energy drinks into Gatordade bottles).
 
 

Member Comments (2)

Only members can post comments.

 
Damn. I wasn't aware that this was a 1-round debate. I would have made my argument more interesting! Oh well. I think I did an OK job regardless.
2 Months Ago
Report It
 
I can see how a child possessing firearms, drugs or explosives could cause legitimate concern for the authorities but would they call in a SWAT team to deal with a schoolboy brandishing a can of Red Bull?

Sorry, I don't see what the problem with energy drinks is?
2 Months Ago
Report It